Pressure Cooker Hollywood Two-Tone Cheesecake is a simple, creamy cheesecake that uses just five basic ingredients. I’ve updated this 70-year-old recipe to make it work for today’s electric pressure cookers—but the classic taste remains just like mom and grandma used to make.
Sigrid, a long-time supporter of Pressure Cooking Today, recently sent me a traditional cheesecake recipe that Epicurious calls the best cheesecake recipe ever. Sigrid calls it her all-time favorite cheesecake. It’s a very simple, classic cheesecake—just cream cheese, eggs, sugar and vanilla—dressed up with a sour cream topping.
As soon as I saw it, I knew it would make a great addition to my collection of pressure cooker cheesecake recipes. I’m so glad that I get to share this classic with all of you!
History of the Hollywood Two-Tone Cheesecake
Epicurious sources this to an 1999 issue of Gourmet magazine, which traced it back to Santa Fe’s Three Cities of Spain coffeehouse in the 1970s. However, Sigrid says the recipe reminded her of a cheesecake her mom used to make called the Hollywood Two-Tone Cheesecake.
I was curious, so I decided to dig a little deeper.
Apparently the Hollywood Two-Tone Cheesecake was created by Antoinette Pope, who ran a successful cooking school and had her own cooking TV show in the 1950s and 60s. She also published a series of cookbooks starting in the 1940s through the early 70s.
This cheesecake recipe was published in several editions of her cookbook. It seems to have made its way into Good Housekeeping and other magazines of the time and was passed from neighbor to neighbor.
It’s just one of those recipes that takes people back in time when they taste it. It’s cheesecake just like mom (or grandma) used to make!
Making Pressure Cooker Hollywood Two-Tone Cheesecake in an Instant Pot
The pressure cooker is the perfect environment for “baking” cheesecake, and your Instant Pot can help you make a fabulous pressure cooker cheesecake—rich, smooth and creamy. Here are some tips to help you get the best results from your Instant Pot or other brand of electric pressure cooker:
Use room temperature ingredients
Since the cheesecake itself has only four ingredients, be sure to follow the instructions carefully. Use room temperature ingredients. This will make such a difference in the smoothness of your finished cheesecake.
You want to mix the cream cheese until it’s soft and smooth; however, you also need to be careful not to overwhip it. Overwhipped cheesecake can rise too much, which affects the texture and appearance. Also, as you mix, regularly scrape down the bowl to ensure the cream cheese, eggs, and sugar are evenly mixed. Also, don’t scrape the beater after mixing—the unbeaten cream cheese stuck to the beaters often adds lumps to your cheesecake batter.
Use an instant-read thermometer
Trying to figure out when a cheesecake is “almost set” or “jiggly enough” in the middle can be difficult, especially for newer cooks. Make your life easier by using an instant-read thermometer. Your cheesecake is ready to move on to the next step when the middle hits 140 to 150°F. (More or less—if your cheesecake is 135 or 153, I’d call that close enough.)
Cook uncovered, then cover
One of the unique things about this recipe is the double cook time. You place the cheesecake in the pressure cooker to “bake” the filling until it’s nearly set, then you remove it, add the topping, and return it to the pressure cooker briefly to set the topping. In this recipe, the cheesecake goes into the first bake uncovered. After you smooth on the sour cream topping, tightly cover the pan with aluminum foil before cooking.
If you prefer, you can cover your cheesecake with foil for both the first and second bake, but you’ll need to increase the cook time on your first bake by a good amount. I’d start with 5 minutes, but it could take longer to get the middle above 140°F.
If you’re still concerned, see more of my best cheesecake making tips here.
Do you remember eating a cheesecake similar to the Hollywood Two-Tone Cheesecake growing up? I’d love to hear from you!
As always, let me know what you think! I’d love to see pictures and comments about your recipe successes in the comments or on my Facebook page!
Do you have a recipe you think would make a great pressure cooker recipe? Please send them to me—I love getting suggestions from my readers! I keep a few slots on my calendar open to add in reader-favorite recipes.
Thanks Sigrid for suggesting I turn the Hollywood Two-Tone Cheesecake into a pressure cooker cheesecake. It was a hit with my family. I’m sure it will be a favorite for your family too.
If you want to maintain more of a contrast between the cheesecake and the sour cream topping, use traditional vanilla in the cheesecake and a clear imitation vanilla in the sour cream filling. You can find the clear vanilla in specialty baking stores and many craft stores. As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases.
For the crust
For the cheesecake
For the two-tone topping
If you want to maintain more of a contrast between the cheesecake and the sour cream topping, use traditional vanilla in the cheesecake and a clear imitation vanilla in the sour cream filling. You can find the clear vanilla in specialty baking stores and many craft stores.
As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases.